Nearly a week after Lee Enterprises rejected Alden Global Capital’s bid to buy the media company, the hedge fund responded Wednesday with a lawsuit accusing Lee’s board of improperly refusing shareholders the opportunity to have their say on the offer.
Lee, owner of the Lincoln Journal Star and nearly every daily newspaper in Nebraska, rejected Alden’s offer to buy the company for $24 a share, or about $141 million, last Thursday because the board of company directors decided that the offer “significantly undervalued” the company.
But Alden argued in his lawsuit that Lee, based in Davenport, Iowa, should not have rejected his offer without telling the hedge fund. Alden also said Lee should not have refused to accept his appointment of three outside directors for technical reasons, so he wants the court to order Lee to accept those nominees.
“Lee’s shareholder-unfriendly, staggered board has shown all the symptoms of deeply entrenched leadership focused more on its own power than on what’s best for the company,” the spokesperson said. Alden, Cameron Gurley.
People also read…
Lee officials did not immediately respond to questions about the lawsuit Wednesday afternoon. But the company has been firm so far in its opposition to Alden.
The New York-based hedge fund, which owns 6.3% of Lee’s shares, became one of the largest newspaper owners in the country after gobbling up all of Tribune’s newspapers earlier this year, but it also acquired reputation for forcing severe cost cuts and layoffs.
Two other hedge funds that are among Lee’s top shareholders, Praetorian Capital and Cannell Capital, said they believe the company is worth far more than Alden is offering.
“I think there’s still tremendous value,” said Carlo Cannell, managing director of the Wyoming-based fund. In fact, Cannell estimates that Lee’s stock could be worth $285 per share within five years if the company does everything right as it continues to shift more to digital than print.
Alden said in his lawsuit that he wanted his $24 offer to be preliminary, and that it could have been changed had the company engaged in constructive talks.
Lee’s stock gained another 12% on Wednesday to close at $40.53 before the lawsuit was announced. Before Alden made its initial offer, the stock was selling for $18.49.
Even before Lee rejected Alden’s offer, he enacted a “poison pill” plan that would make it more expensive for Alden to buy out Lee’s stock once he owns more than 10% of the company. At this point, the plan would allow other Lee shareholders to buy shares at a 50% discount or possibly get free shares for every share they already own.
Lee owns the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, the Buffalo News and dozens of other newspapers.
Unions that represent journalists at these newspapers have strongly opposed Alden because they are concerned about what the hedge fund would do.
Among his other Nebraska newspapers are the Omaha World-Herald, Grand Island Independent, North Platte Telegraph, Kearney Hub, and Scottsbluff Star-Herald.
Alden has purchased about 200 publications across the country in recent years through a series of acquisitions. Besides the Tribune newspapers, Alden also owns the Denver Post, the Orange County Register and the Boston Herald.
Lee Enterprises board unanimously rejects Alden hedge fund bid
Hedge fund Alden offers to buy Lee Enterprises, owner of the Journal Star
Top photos from the Journal Star of December
Top photos from the Journal Star of December
Empty offices in the Atrium building frame the Capitol. FRANCIS GARDLER, newspaper star
Francois Gardler
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Model trains are on their tracks on Sunday, December 12, 2021 at the Foley Sign Company. EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Lincoln Pius X’s Jack Hastreiter (32) passes the ball past Bellevue West’s Josiah Dotzler in the fourth quarter on Saturday, Dec. 11, 2021, at Bellevue West High School. EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Bella Cravens (14) of Nebraska leaps to deny Tonysha Curry (24) of Indiana State a pass to teammate Mya Glanton (00) in the first half on Saturday, Dec. 11, 2021 at Pinnacle Bank arena. FRANCIS GARDLER, newspaper star
FRANCIS GARDLER, NEWSPAPER STAR
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Lincoln East’s Jared Townsley (10) scores two goals past Kearney’s Parker Wise (11) in the fourth quarter, Friday, Dec. 10, 2021, at Lincoln East High School. EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Lincoln Midwest Ballet Company dancer Grace Fry performs as the Norwood Park Elementary School student jester in an abbreviated performance of “The Nutcracker” for the Backstage at the Ballet Experience on Friday, December 10, 2021. GWYNETH ROBERTS, Newspaper Star
GWYNETH ROBERTS, newspaper star
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

An 80,000-pound tanker crashes into a 62-inch concrete barrier at 50 mph during a test of the barrier that is shorter and thinner than current standards Wednesday, Dec. 8, 2021, at Midwest Roadside Safety Facility. GWYNETH ROBERTS, Newspaper Star
GWYNETH ROBERTS, newspaper star
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Wes Kembel (left) cleans his house with the help of his friend Jordan Meals after a tornado hit the day before Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021. JUSTIN WAN, Journal Star
JUSTIN WAN Journal Star
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

City workers remove a fallen tree from a car after a storm Wednesday, Dec. 15, 2021, at 13th and Pawnee streets. JUSTIN WAN, Newspaper Star
JUSTIN WAN Journal Star
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Winds toppled a hackberry tree in Antelope Park on December 15.
GWYNETH ROBERTS, newspaper star
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

The Downtown Lincoln Association decorated the area with Christmas-themed icons like these frosty trees on Wednesday, December 1, 2021 for the Lincoln North Pole attraction in Tower Square. FRANCIS GARDLER, newspaper star
FRANCIS GARDLER, NEWSPAPER STAR
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Lincoln Southwest’s Freddie Wallace (10) heads to the basket against Papio South’s Taylor Mauch (bottom right) and Eke Djibril (top right) on Thursday, Dec. 2, 2021, at Lincoln Southwest High School. FRANCIS GARDLER, newspaper star
FRANCIS GARDLER, NEWSPAPER STAR
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Fourth grader Marquavious Irving writes a math formula, Friday, Dec. 3, 2021, at Kahoa Elementary School. JUSTIN WAN, Newspaper Star
JUSTIN WAN Journal Star
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Ally Batenhorst (14) of Nebraska will kill Campbell in the first set in the first round of the NCAA playoffs on Friday, December 3, 2021 at Devaney Sports Center. EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Charlie (10, left) and Will Simon (13) greet Eric Fass from their car as they drive in the parade welcoming him home Saturday, Dec. 4, 2021, on S. 26th Road. EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Cathy (left) and Mark Ebers choose a Christmas tree with Sam, their six-year-old Australian Shepherd and cattle dog mix, from the few trees that remain unclaimed in Prior Pines on Saturday, December 4, 2021, in Prior Pines . EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Lincoln Pius X’s Joe Andreasen (left) grapples with Norris’ Cooper Spaulding in a 170-pound match on Saturday, Dec. 4, 2021, at the Lincoln Pius X Invitational. FRANCIS GARDLER, newspaper star
FRANCIS GARDLER, NEWSPAPER STAR
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Lauren Stivrins (26), Aly Batenhorst (14), Lexi Rodriguez (8), and Callie Schwarzenbach (25) of Nebraska greet fans with a victory lap after beating Florida State 3-0 on Saturday, December 4, 2021 , during the NCAA Second Round at Devaney Sports Center. FRANCIS GARDLER, newspaper star
FRANCIS GARDLER, NEWSPAPER STAR
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Lincoln Stars’ Michael Mastrodomenico (4) evades Tri-City’s Jeremy Wlimer (13) in the second period Saturday, December 4, 2021 at the Ice Box. EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Brayden Burt (9) tees off from the ninth hole of the Scott Whitcomb Memorial Disc golf course as his father Kelsey looks on Sunday, Dec. 5, 2021, at Tierra Briarhurst Park. EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

York’s Shaylynn Wahl plays against Ogallala in Game 3 of the State Unified Bowling Class B Championship Game on Monday, Dec. 6, 2021 at Sun Valley Lanes & Games. EAKIN HOWARD, Journal star
Journal Star EAKIN HOWARD
Top photos from the Journal Star of December

Workers and volunteers pull up the Christmas tree at the Capitol on Monday, Dec. 6, 2021. JUSTIN WAN, Journal Star
JUSTIN WAN Journal Star